Keywords: Verdict in favor of the defendents in the case of Martin Luther v. Luther Borden, et. al. - NARA - 278280.tif Scope and content This document is from the file for the case of Martin Luther v Luther Borden This is a suit for trespass against a group of Rhode Island state militia who acting under martial law broke into Martin Luther's house in the middle of the night searched the premises and threatened its inhabitants Luther claimed that the legislation establishing martial law was void because the charter government which proclaimed martial law was not the legal government of Rhode Island The defendents claimed that the declaration of martial law was legal and that they were acting under the orders of their superior officers when they entered the house to search for Luther who was an important supporter of Thomas W Dorr who had organized a people's government The decision of the US Circuit Court in favor of the defendents was appealed to the US Supreme Court The US Supreme Court however feeling that the case was political in nature refused to rule on the issues and returned the case to the US Circuit Court This case was an important case in the historic events commonly known as the Dorr Thomas W Dorr Rebellion General notes 278280 Local identifier U S Circuit Court for the District of Rhode Island 1790 - 01/01/1912 NARA's Northeast Region Boston NRAAB 380 Trapelo Road Waltham MA 02452-6399 11/1843 - 11/1843 Record group Record Group 21 Records of District Courts of the United States 1685 - 2004 Record group ARC 350 Case Files compiled 11/1790 - 12/1911 Series ARC 278236 File unit Martin Luther v Luther Borden et al 10/06/1842 - 12/1848 File unit ARC 278271 Variant control numbers NAIL Control Number NRAB-21-CASECCRI-24LAW-I yes Other versions NARA-cooperation PD-USGov Documents in English Supreme Court of the United States cases |